“Death and Life are in the Tongue”* – A Case of Hate Speech
The case arose from four statements about the Israel–Palestine conflict made by Bongani Masuku, who at the time was the international relations secretary of the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU). He made the statements in in the context of the Gaza War.
THE SUPREME COURT OF APPEAL OF SOUTH AFRICA JUDGMENT - SAFLII
‘Death and life are in the tongue’ – lessons from the Bongani Masuku hate speech case. Given the enduring legacy of the Nazi horrors inflicted on European Jewry, it has become commonplace for antisemites of every stripe to level baseless, insulting and profoundly demeaning charges against Jews that they themselves have become like Nazis. ‘Death and life are in the tongue’ – lessons from the Bongani ...
In March , the South African Jewish Board of Deputies (“SAJBD”) lodged a complaint of hate speech with the South African Human Rights Commission (“SAHRC”). This followed a series of remarks made by Mr Bongani Masuku (“Mr Masuku”) while representing the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU).
Bongani Masuku - Wikipedia
In summary, the ConCourt found sufficient grounds to uphold the original SAHRC ruling finding Masuku, then international relations secretary of Cosatu, guilty of hate speech and directing him to. Hate Speech – A look at the case of Bongani Masuku
Bongani Masuku was a South African vocalist best known as the backing vocalist of Johnny Clegg's band. [1] In addition he also toured with I Muvrini on three European tours. [2] He was shot dead during an altercation with thieves on May 17, , aged [3] [4]. Bongani Masuku in respect of the protracted feud between Israel and Palestine in the Middle East. In March 2009, the South African Jewish Board of Deputies (“SAJBD”) lodged a complaint of hate speech with the South African Human Rights Commission (“SAHRC”). This followed a series of remarks made by Mr Bongani Masuku (“Mr Masuku”) while representing the Congress of South African Trade Unions (COSATU).
Mr Masuku currently has a case of hate speech being reviewed against him at the South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC). South African Human Rights Commission v Masuku; Court: Constitutional Court of South Africa: Full case name: South African Human Rights Commission on behalf of South African Jewish Board of Deputies v Bongani Masuku and Another: Decided: 16 February 2022 () Docket nos. CCT 14/19: Citations [2022] ZACC 5; 2022 (4) SA 1 (CC); 2022 (7) BCLR 850 (CC).
SAHRC obo SAJBD vs Bongani Masuku: The ConCourt judgment
In February and March , Bongani Masuku, representing the Congress of South African Trade Unions (Cosatu), made a series of remarks regarding the Israel-Palestine conflict. Firstly, on February. Bongani Masuku - Wikipedia
The Masuku judgment shows that the Constitutional Court has settled the approach for hate speech cases under section 10(1). The Court set out the test and factors to be followed in the Qwelane judgment, and then itself followed this test in deciding both the Qwelane case and now the Masuku case. I’m sorry for 13-year-old ‘hate’ speech, union boss tells ...
"In the spirit of conciliation and acceptance of diversity‚ the SAJBD hopes that Bongani Masuku and Cosatu will comply with the court’s judgment that Mr Masuku apologise to the Jewish. South African Human Rights Commission v Masuku - Wikipedia The saga dates back to the early months of 2009 when, in the aftermath of a bloody three-week conflict between Israel and Hamas in Gaza, Masuku made a series of inflammatory attacks, both verbal.Cosatu's Bongani Masuku must apologise for comments directed ... ‘Death and life are in the tongue’ – lessons from the Bongani Masuku hate speech case. Given the enduring legacy of the Nazi horrors inflicted on European Jewry, it has become commonplace for antisemites of every stripe to level baseless, insulting and profoundly demeaning charges against Jews that they themselves have become like Nazis.Masuku case summary - SOUTH AFRICAN HUMAN RIGHTS ... - Studocu Bongani Masuku was a South African vocalist best known as the backing vocalist of Johnny Clegg's band. [1] In addition he also toured with I Muvrini on three European tours. [2] He was shot dead during an altercation with thieves on May 17, 2014, aged 50. [3] [4].